Article written by

9 comments

This comment has been deleted

ariess
ariess

These guys made the roster because they are eligible to be drafted away from the giants.  Just a protection move.

RogerM
RogerM

@ariess That's true of every 40 man move made at the end of November by every org. That's the point of this move.  Still nice to know we're hanging on to Noonan and Escobar and Heston.  Dunning's just an arm strength kid at this point, but that's a decent enough reason to keep the inventory.

This comment has been deleted

Foothills Ryan
Foothills Ryan

Dude,  you're tough with nothing but tough love for the minor league depth crew.  Juan Perez. hit over .300 with 11 HRs in the Eastern League.  I'm sure that translates to hitting over .300 with 15+ HRs in the PCL.  Not bad for a guy who's penciled in as emergency depth.  He'll be in the mix for 5th OF at some point in time during the next 162.  Same goes for Noonan.  If Crawford and Scutaro man the middle and Arias is the back up utilitify infielder, then someone needs to step up and replace Emmanuel Burriss.  Noonan is the guy unless Sabean dumpster dives or if Ryan Theriot wants to come back.  You didn't expect Brown or Panik to make the 40 so soon, did you ?

RogerM
RogerM

@Foothills Ryan Important to note that Perez posted those numbers, not only at a very advanced age for AA, but also in his second full season there.  His first year in AA, when at 25 he was already old for the level, he put up much worse numbers.  He does do a little of everything well though, and he's easy to root for. Never can figure out how he get so much pop out of such a tiny frame.

This comment has been deleted

TSF
TSF

The lack of power arms in the minors troubles me. Flamethrowers without control might find it someday, but control pitchers without velocity will likely never harness the heat. I don't think the Giants should pump up with nothing but 95 mph+ fastball guys like the Cardinals did, but it does make Santiago Casilla a lot more valuable to the Giants than he should be.

RogerM
RogerM

@TSF Well you should be happy soon, they've drafted about 30 dozen of those guys in the last two years.

ariess
ariess

I am not even luke warm, or lint like fuzzy with this move.

Will_the_Shrill
Will_the_Shrill

/Brian Sabean opens These_Might_Be_Prospects.xls

/Clicks *sort batting average*

/Adds Nick Noonan to 40-man

 

Every post you give me at least one lulz moment.