Article written by

7 comments
Alex Mannings
Alex Mannings

I'm fine with Hector Sanchez in the infield. Something's clicked with him and Zito. His error yesterday was annoying, but minor compared to Crawford's displays or anyone else's. Moreover, Posey has committed more errors than he has, and he's also impatient at the plate (like most Giants). I watched his first at-bat yesterday. Every strike was a foul until the swinging-strike out. If that doesn't epitomise Giants htting, I don't know what does. Plus, Sanchez can swing the bat well.

Damon
Damon

I personally don't understand how Gillaspie has come up through the minors as a 3B if his arm is so terrible. What's his natural position supposed to be- second? All I know is that we now have 5 guys getting regular playing time who were down on the farm at some point last season. That's bad.

TSF
TSF

I don't thinks this permutation is as bad as it looks at first glance. Gillaspie and Edlefsen's errors were inexcusable, but that offense almost put up 3 runs last night, had Hector Sanchez's double not been caught by Loney. That would have been competitive had the Dodgers not blown the game open in the 8th. Here's hoping the Giants have less rotten luck and the hard lessons stay learned.

Frozendarkness
Frozendarkness

It's actually confusing to me because not only is Conor Gillaspie terrible offensively and defensively, he has a terrible arm. It's literally one of the worst options you can have at third base. 

chatomarkin
chatomarkin

Hate to add this to your list of bad infielders from last night's game, but you forgot "a stud of a catcher who just isn't hacking it at first." Poor Posey looked like he was about to explode after his 8th inning error.

 

Is Gillaspie and his .158/.211/.368 really the best option at third? Why not give Pill a try over there? There's no way Pill could play bunts worse than Gillaspie did last night.

ariess
ariess

 @chatomarkin Maybe Pill could be at least as good as CG at third, but Arias was

surprisingly good at short, and maybe he could be a better option than Crawford. But for now

it looks like Arias may shift to third with Crawford at short.  But Crawford's fielding seems to

be affected by his continued lack of hitting.  Belt at first today save some errors with some

nice scoops.

yogi berra
yogi berra

@ariess @chatomarkin

Since the Giants already have three First Basemen (Belt, Pill & Huff), I don't understand why they aren't playing Posey at Third?

Third Base is kinda like catching pitches in the dirt, only different. He certainly has the arm for Third....and once, in a college game he played 9 different positions, in a 9 inning game!

This comment has been deleted

This comment has been deleted