Article written by

8 comments
LeviDavis
LeviDavis

I don't quite get the Tommy Joseph love. I hope he is a great player, but I'm taking the overnight transformation from not-good-enough-to-stick-at-catcher-and-will-have-to-move-to-first, to best defensive catcher in the league with a large grain of salt. And he does need to stick at catcher, because the numbers (92 wRC+) are not impressive for a player on any of the four corners. He hits for power, but doesn't really do anything else well at the plate. And even his good numbers for a catcher need to be taken with a grain of salt; Marc Hulet said in his chat the other day that PCL and Cal league stats are the least reliable (Let's not forget the monster seasons Charlie Culberson and Thomas Neal put up there). He's still young and has plenty of talent to grow into, but I find it interesting how we have just cast aside all caution.

Chris Quick
Chris Quick

Cast aside all caution? No way. I don't think anyone has done that. His approach is horrible, but he's really young for his league, hitting for power, AND reports have been positive on his defense. That's enough for a top ten prospect on ANY team.

LeviDavis
LeviDavis

Just curious, where are good places to get scouting reports on these guys?

LeviDavis
LeviDavis

Any free ones? I used to subscribe to those, but hard times...John Sickles and Marc Hulet have become my default ones, though they rarely touch on the Giants.

Chris Quick
Chris Quick

Baseball America is probably the best place. I also like KG's work on BP.

nate
nate

have we really gotten so addicted to sabermetric stats that we can't realize that Timmy has been better than Cain and much better than Madbum? Also, i'm surprised you didn't mention Kershaw. What he's doing for a team that's far inferior to the Phillies, is pretty impressive.

Chris Quick
Chris Quick

If I don't look at FIP scores or read about wOBA, I get all shaky.