Letters to Brian Sabean and Bruce Bochy « Bay City Ball – A Giants Blog

Letters to Brian Sabean and Bruce Bochy

In the exquisite film The Shawshank Redemption, “Andy” Dufresne (Tim Robbins) wrote a letter per day to the State, requesting that they fund his library project. Eventually, it worked.

Sadly, I bet some Giants fan out there has a desire for Brandon Belt to play first base over Aubrey Huff for the San Francisco Giants. I bet that desire is so strong that it even exceeds that of Andy. The main reason that I believe this is true is simple: This is real life. Andy obviously wanted it more, a lot more even, but that film was just make believe. And besides, baseball fans are sort of loony.

And so it begins…

- – - – -

18 July 2011

Dear Mr. Bochy and Mr. Sabean,

I’ve been watching most of the games this season, and the offense really stinks. I guess you two fellas, as smart as you are, can see that. But I also noticed that one of your worst players is Aubrey Huff. I really like him. Remember when he was really good and wore a red thong underneath his uniform? That was fun. I like winning the World Series.

I changed my mind – I really love Huff. He was awesome last year. If I could, I’d go out and have a 12-pack with him and talk all about the 2010 season. But what I wouldn’t do is let him play first base every day and bat cleanup. I’d let Brandon Belt do that. Well, maybe not bat cleanup, but I’d let him play.

He has played 43 games this season in Triple-A. He has 11 doubles, seven home runs and 29 runs batted in. Best of all, he has a .324 average and is getting on base a ton. But I guess you two smart guys knew that.

I saw this hit chart for Huff yesterday in an article entitled “4-3.” I think  they called it that because, when a player grounds out to second, that’s what you write in the score book. The guy that wrote it uses a lot of weird stats, so sometimes I can’t follow.

But I’ll tell you, that hit chart was straightforward enough. Most of the balls put into play by Huff were clustered around second base. I later found out that the chart wasn’t real, and that the writer had doctored it. That’s what concerned me. Because I thought it was real. And some other fans did, too.

So please consider playing him. Belt I mean. I also like Belt, and it sure seems like he’s a swell Southern guy too, and that he could help the team score more runs.

Sincerely,

The Biggest Giants Fan

- – - – -

19 July 2011

Dear Mr. Bochy and Mr. Sabean,

Great move on getting Keff Jeppinger. Oops! Jeff Keppinger I mean. My friend says he hits lefties really well, which makes him an ideal platoon for Mike Fontenot. Whatever that means. I liked that movie.

But anyway, the real reason I am writing you is because I see that you got my letter. Thank you so much for thinking so highly of my opinion. You two guys are a real couple of geniuses – Which, respectfully, is plain enough to see by the size of your head, Bruce.  So it’s rather flattering to a guy like me, the biggest Giants fan there is.

Wow! What a splash he made in a hurry, almost literally! To think that he hit a home run in his first at-bat and a game-winning double in the same game, well… I guess it was just amazing. But you two fellas know that.

Anyway, thanks again.

Sincerely,

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. Tough break for the kid that he has to face Clayton Kershaw tomorrow. Even if he doesn’t get another hit, I know you two chaps will see he’s a real tough lefty, a Cy Young-type lefty, and that there’s no reason to bench him for it.

- – - – -

22 July 2011

Dear Mr. Bochy and Mr. Sabean,

Like I said, it was a tough break that Belt didn’t do anything against Kershaw. But then again, nobody else did, either.

I sure thought that Belt would get the start against Shaun Marcum, because he throws right-handed and Belt hits left-handed and he did so good the other day and he was doing so great in the minors and… oh well. I guess maybe he’ll start tomorrow.

I’m sure you two know what you’re doing, and that Belt maybe just needed a day off.

Sincerely,

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. I am thinking of getting a Belt t-shirt. Which color is your favorite?

- – - – -

23 July 2011

Dear Bochy and Sabean,

I just checked the lineup and Brandon Belt is not it. I’m beginning to grow concerned. Is he hurt? I know he pinch hit and struck out yesterday, but it didn’t seem like cause for alarm.

I hope this letter finds each of you in good health, along with Belt. Please write me back. Or better yet, if Belt is in the lineup tomorrow, I will know that all is well.

Sincerely,

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. I bought the all black t-shirt with the numbers on it. It’s my favorite thing.

- – - – -

24 July 2011

Dear Bruce and Brian,

I watched the game today. It was really awesome that you let Brandon Belt play again. Not only because he did really good by getting two hits and getting on base three times, but because he is my favorite player.

I must say, though, I was a little surprised he was playing outfield. It doesn’t seem like his natural position. Plus, I remember everyone saying that he was such a superb first baseman, and even J.T. Snow, who was like Keith Hernandez at first without the cocaine and the mustache, said he was excellent.

And also, Aubrey Huff, the guy that I really like but don’t want to play so much, he hasn’t looked so hot lately. But I guess maybe a few outfielders were banged up. Ya, that’s it.

But I guess you can’t argue with results! A win! Keep up the good work.

Sincerely,

The Biggest Giants Fan

- – - – -

24 July 2011

Dear Bruce and Brian,

Have you heard of a guy named Grant Brisbee? He writes this weblog, and it’s called McCovey Chronicles. Anyway, he wrote this hilarious joke post today while the Giants were visiting the White House. It was called The real reason why the Giants are visiting the White House. It was all a joke, you know, in good fun.

So he was like talking about how someone had planted a bomb at the White House, and how Huff had been called in to disarm it. And the room was shaped like a baseball diamond and had lasers protecting the bomb. So then he would hit one of those grounders he does so often to second, and that would disarm the bomb. I guess I’m bad at jokes.

You should just read it, because we all did and we all laughed over and over and over, and everyone said Grant was brilliant. And I agreed. Everyone did, really. I will just copy it down.

http://www.mccoveychronicles.com/2011/7/25/2293023/the-real-reason-why-the-giants-are-visiting-the-white-house

Just type that into your lapt… never mind.

I guess it seems like everyone realizes how bad he’s been this year. It’s too bad, too, because I really like that guy. Huff. He’s a really nice guy and a really good player. Well, at least he was. Especially last year. What a great story that was.

Well, anyway, it sure is a good thing that we (oops, I hate when I do that) the Giants have a great player like Brandon Belt to step right in and take his place.

There’s this writer for ESPN named Keith Law… he’s a bit condescending at times, maybe on account of being so short and going to Harvard and working for the Blue Jays…anyway, he thinks Belt is going to be a heck of a player. And Law (Klaw, they call him) is smart, and he really knows his stuff. Actually, he thinks Belt is a heck of a player now. I’m sure it’s not news to you two, though, you’re too smart.

Sincerely,

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. Tell Bobby Evans good job for drafting him. What a steal! Belt I mean.

- – - – -

26 July 2011

Dear B&B,

That sucked. I sure was hoping the Giants would put up a better fight against the Phillies after the rivalry they forged when they knocked them out last Fall. That was awesome.

I guess it’s tough to blame Zito, considering he didn’t have much time to prepare with Timmy coming down with the stomach flu so all of a sudden. But boy, did he ever get bombed. The first inning sort of looked like  batting practice. Oh well.

But the real reason I’m writing you is to ask about Belt. The Giants were playing against another right-handed pitcher yesterday, and so I thought Belt would play. I was sure of it. He had the two hits and the walk against the Brewers.

But I just remembered this Worley guy was a rookie. I guess maybe you thought he was left handed or something. Ya, that’s probably it. I mean that has to be it. You guys are too smart. Way too smart.

Regards,

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. Don’t you guys have scouting reports that tell you which hand the opposing pitcher throws with? Oh well.

- – - – -

27 July 2011

Dear B&B,

Wow! What a day! The Giants beat them Phillies and the Giants get Carlos Beltran all in the same day! I hope they win a World Series now, and this surely has to make you guys more of a favorite than you were before.

Who’d you give up for him, anyway? Oh well. Who cares!? Carlos Beltran!

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. I couldn’t help but notice that Brandon Belt wasn’t in the lineup. He did get to run some, and I suppose Hamels is a tough lefty and that he didn’t do so well against Kershaw. But the more I think about it, Huff is a lefty, too. I guess it doesn’t matter. Why? Because tomorrow the Giants are playing those Phillies again, and this time them Phillies will be up against the Killer Belts!

- – - – -

27 July 2011

Dear B&B,

First, I apologize for the second letter in one day. It feels sort of like when people keep hitting “All Reply” on their emai… never mind.

Aubrey Huff was batting today, and I noticed that he tried to do a drag bunt. Oh ya, and he was batting cleanup. I’ve never seen that before. I watch a lot of baseball. I was just thinking that he might be trying to tell you two something.

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. You guys are really smart.

- – - – -

28 July 2011

Dear you two,

I heard somewhere today that someone said you guys think that Brandon Belt could be this season’s Travis Ishikawa. I don’t understand what that even means. Please urgently reply, because I need confirmation that this was some sort of sick joke.

Last night, there was a report from a reputable station that you were going to designate for assignment (whatever that means) Pat Burrell and send Brandon Belt to Triple-A Fresno (wherever that is). I think the designate means you are getting rid of him. I think Fresno is some not-so-great place in the Valley. Anyway, I thought both ideas were stupid but I wasn’t that surprised that you would choose to do that. I don’t know. You guys are always doing something that seems strange to others, and I think that’s because you’re so smart.  

But most of all, I was glad it wasn’t true.

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. I read this weblog today about Aubrey Huff and how he hasn’t been good for a long time. They showed his stats over the last year, not just this year, and they weren’t good. He also showed how they are making almost the exact same amount of money and hitting almost the same. I didn’t know this.

Actually, it was weird because the weblog showed that Rowand was hitting better than Huff even though nobody likes Rowand and they hate his stance and they think he should get the designate thing, too. There was also something about center field being a more important position. I guess I didn’t understand that. First base always has the best players with the most Hall of Famers with the most MVP’s. Oh well.

Anyway, I guess the point was that Huff is as bad as Rowand is now. I mean, with the money you need to pay him and how good at baseball he is. But I guess you guys already knew that. On account of being so smart.

I copy and pasted where I read it, but I don’t know that  you’ll have a way to access it.

http://www.baycityball.com/2011/07/28/huff-and-rowand-not-so-different/

- – - – -

28 July 2011

Dear you two,

It’s me again, The Biggest Giants Fan. Sorry, again, for another day with another two letters. I checked the lineup. Belt is not playing. Huff is still batting fifth, and that’s still a pretty important spot in the order.

I guess you two know what you’re doing, you know, because you’re so smart. Brian, you, you drafted Derek Jeter. Bruce, you, well you were praised as a genius all last postseason for your bullpen work. You were brilliant.

I want to be mad about Belt not playing, but I guess you two know what you’re doing. But like I said, you two are so smart. Smarter than anyone else in the world. You must be, because that’s how many people think Belt should be playing over Huff. Everyone in the whole world.

The Biggest Giants Fan

P.S. I found a bunch of Aubrey Huff t-shirts in a dumpster a few blocks away from the ballpark in San Francisco. They had a bunch of stickers on them with marked-down prices. The sticker on top said “Free!”

If you like, I can stop by the ballpark when you get back into town tomorrow. You guys can probably find a way to sell these.

Because you two are so smart.

 Follow Rory Paap on Twitter (@paapfly).

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

That was amazing. I was afraid of the read at first because of its length, but it was well worth it. "P.S. Don’t you guys have scouting reports that tell you which hand the opposing pitcher throws with? Oh well." Great voice throughout.

Excellent. I'm glad you enjoyed it.

Awesome post. Unfortunately, Huff is also maturing - except that's also called "the decline phase". Belt should be playing more.

Huff may not win the NL batting title this year, but he's on pace to win the Giants batting title. Near the top in batting average, leader in RBI and hits, and one behind Panda in HRs. Couple that with a great clubhouse personality, leadership, and maturity, and I feel like he's a cash cow we have to squeeze as much as we can out of over the next two seasons. Ease Brandon Belt in as Bochy has been doing. He'll get his time. For our offense-challenged Giants, Huff is a 3-4-5 batter. That double last night with two outs for our second run was huge. He comes through when needed. My two cents...

Yeah, .239/.296/.364 is NOT what I want out of my 3-4-5 hitter, not even for my 8th hitter. and NOT what I want out of the best offensive position in 1B. Last thing, RBI is a terrible stat and anyone hitting 4th or 5th can rack up RBI just by hitting there. Belt is .232/ .338/.348 which isnt much better, but it is better and he has done much better of late.

RBI is a terrible stat? The giants don't get a lot of hits but every time we win its because a couple of guys step up and do whatever it takes to get a run in. RBI is as important a stat as any, especially when were talking about the Giants and all you need is 1-4 runs to win a ballgame.

Finally, this site has gone mainstream. Wow, just wow. RBI is not at all an important stat because the variables involved in whether a player gets an RBI have little to do with the player. For example batting behind Barry Bonds who once had an OBP of over .600 is going to produce a lot more opportunities to drive in runs than batting behind Shawon Dunston who once had an OBP below .300. A player could hit .200 behind Bonds and drive in more runs then a guy who hit .350 behind Dunston. There's probably a better explanation than that, but yes, RBI is the worst stat there is next to the Win.

Yes, Huff is technically leading the giants in batting average with a .239 average but that is only because he is the only one qualified for the batting title. Sandoval has played in 40 fewer games and yet only has 19 fewer hits in over 150 fewer ABs and is beating him in HR. So no Huff is not on pace to win the giants batting title and the only possible way he will win it is if no one else qualifies. It isn't that impressive to be number 1 out of 1.

This situation makes me think of a comment made by Terry Francona in a piece on Grantland: "But it's about more than numbers," [Francona] says. "I remember a few years ago, we're playing the Yankees on national TV and one of the kids in baseball ops — he's not here now — says to me about five hours before the game, 'You got Mike Lowell in the lineup?' And I say, 'Yeah.' And he says he doesn't do well in the matchup with Chien-Ming Wang, who was pitching for the Yankees. "I say to the kid, 'So you don't want me to play him?' And he says, 'Yeah' and I tell him, 'OK. Look over there. There's Mikey Lowell's locker. He's over there. You go tell Mikey Lowell he's not playing in a national TV game against our biggest rival 'cause your fucking numbers tell us not to play him. See what kind of reaction you get from him and then come back and tell me.' Course Mikey Lowell played that game." Huff is such an outspoken personality and presence in that clubhouse that maybe there is a fear of disrupting the locker room chemistry and camaraderie by favoring Belt over Huff even though the statistical evidence is starting to become overwhelming. As someone who has never played on a professional sports team (surprise!), I don't know how much that sort of thing impacts performance or morale. Honestly, Huff is probably going to have to drop off a cliff in terms of production to the point where if Bochy were to start Belt on a regular basis it would not ruffle any feathers (something he seems keen on avoiding). I am very much in favor of seeing Belt start on a regular basis, but I think fans and bloggers often don't do justice to the complexity of the situation since we can only assess the on-field production and are not surrounded by these players on a regular basis.

I see your point, and it's a good point. Thanks for the comment. I also think, though, that there's a bit of a difference from a guy playing in what is perceived to be a bad matchup for him (one game) then a guy who has been playing every day and has been bad for a year, beyond horrendous for four months. And I may be wrong, but I'll submit he can have just as much of an impact, chemistry-wise, while sitting on the bench. Who knows really. I just don't buy it. Finally, from a comfortability standpoint, if Bochy can't sit Huff down and tell him he's moving in Belt because he's not producing (*at all*), what the hell are the Giants paying him for?

I love you Paap, but if Huff turns it around these articles are going to look pretty stupid. Belt is still maturing and we are in a pennant race as well as a championship defense. Huff has been there and also is a pretty important guy in the clubhouse. Plus, the Giants aren't really doing too shabby in my opinion (just got beltran, pitching heating up like last year, 4th best record in the Majors AND we still got Philly's number).

Thanks for the "love," Chap. I'm very okay with looking stupid if Huff turns it around. After all, that'll mean good things for the Giants, which is all that I want. Also, I wouldn't be much of a writer if I wasn't willing to express my opinion for fear of looking stupid. As far as Belt maturing, I don't see how he's doing that as playing Ishikawa's role. I don't see how sitting Huff should prevent him from being a strong figure in the clubhouse -- it'd be on him if it did. And I definitely agree they aren't looking too shabby.

Agreed. And the biggest thing to me is, what's there to lose? It's not like Belt could do much worse. Also, if Belt can develop in the Ishikawa role, why can't Huff break out of his funk in the same role? Any way you slice it, there's almost no reason not to give Belt a look.

Brilliant. Couldn't agree more. And If you'r going to start Huff, dont bat him 4th or 5th.

One day outta five, he should hit ninth! At this point I've got as much confidence in Bumgarner's swing as I do Huff's. The "Mr. 4-3" nickname is the most appropriate nickname I've heard in a long time.

Very funny, I was waiting for "Brooks was here"

Brooks was awesome. So, my fiancé... She doesn't love this movie. Break it off?

Over the past 5 games hes played in huff has an obp of .473 so he may be turning it around. However I don't believe he should be hitting clean up

Ya, maybe. But it's the 100 before that which have me concerned.

Totally feel you there, obp over last 6 up to .478 after todays game, lets hope he keeps this up also hes been on base 6 nights in a row which is a good sign.

I'd go ahead and continue reading this site, but in the meantime, go ahead and google "small sample size" and read up. I'm sure you're a super smart guy just like Brian and Bruce so you'll have no problem figuring it out, but it might be some good reading. I read here that 6 games doesn't really mean anything and is just something called "noise" whatever that means (maybe it's really loud at those games?).

Never said it meant anything just saying maybe its a good sign.. of course if you would look at the entire system is obp is terrible. I'm just saying its improving. Now you can be a sarcastic ass and think your being clever, or you can just take the comment for what its worth. Highlighting a 6 game stretch where he has been much better than he has the entire season.

Wow spelling problems "the entire season his obp is terrible******"

Sarcastic ass? Apparently my reputation precedes me. In fact I'd like to request a graph be made by one Chris Quick on my sarcastic assyness. It's all good though, just joking with you. Didn't mean to offend.

I had to cut my comment in half: I assume their hope is that he has been trying too hard in the face of the loss of the performance of Posey, Burrell, and Franchez. With Beltran now being the top dog, maybe he will loosen up and start hitting like he did last season. I think if he doesn't start hitting soon, the Giants will start playing Belt more, particularly if he can hit like he did in the other game. He will need to earn his way into the starting position in the majors, and what he has done so far in the majors does not scream "starter". He will either have to be patient or start hitting when he gets his chances, that would get Bochy's attention fast.

There's how good Belt will be eventually and how good he is now. I feel pretty good that all the accolades he has gotten will come to fruition. Eventually. Now, he can't control his strikeout rate very well in AAA and has been just as bad in the majors. That has been Ishikawa's problem too, striking out too much. He is not going to do much in the majors striking out so much. Now, if he had been hitting better in the majors, that is one thing, but he hasn't. Meanwhile, Huff's rope is pretty much gone now, and he has hit .263/.326/.368/.694 since the ASG. I think the Giants will give Huff one more chance to turn things around - when a hitter has hit like he did in 2010 and 2008, you should give him the chance to figure things out.

Calendar

July 2011
M T W T F S S
« Jun   Aug »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Archives