Article written by

3 comments
www.PaapFly.com
www.PaapFly.com

I suspect every Braves fan will say Heyward, every Giants fan Posey. It's pretty much a split vote that's going to exceptionally close. I think this series may set one of the two apart from the other. Fun!

Merkled
Merkled

Don't they submit the votes before the postseason starts? I thought I remember that all voting is done prior to the postseason but I could be wrong. Maybe it comes down to this: If you were starting your team around one rookie player, which one would you pick based on what you have seen this season? Seems worth noting that in 2008 Geovany Soto and Joey Votto were almost identical in their stat lines but Soto got a significant amount of votes over Votto for what I can guess is a position advantage. Sounds like history with the writers gives the edge to Posey even though he was at a disadvantage with less PA.