Article written by

7 comments
Chris
Chris

Yup, you're totally right.

Nibbler
Nibbler

The two people above him on wCH/C are Braden Looper and Kenshin Kawakami. Braden Looper has thrown 1 changeup all season while Kenshin has thrown 11. So they definitely should not be anywhere in the best changeup discussion.

Chris
Chris

@Nibbler I was going by the 'per 100 pitches' linear weight, but it probably makes more sense to use the total value at this point in the season instead of pro-rating things.

Nibbler
Nibbler

Lincecum has the best Changeup in baseball, not the third best.

Giantsfan4life
Giantsfan4life

The flyball data you shared is very interesting. And of course, a sOPS+ is a statistical outlier. Among those flyballs which fell in in 2008 were 11 triples, 25 doubles. The point you're making seems very well supported: that as this season progresses, a few of those long fly balls will find triples alley again, and we'll see his sOPS+ rise some. Some. A bump in his offensive production. Sure. But the guy's 28 years old. This is who he is. This isn't Pedro Sandoval, whose growth has already been remarkable, and who's only 22. I think you're right--Lewis could be poised for a stronger second half. But what does that mean for the long-term success of this Giants' team? We can break it down several ways: Lewis vs. Schierholtz, either of them vs. Bowker, Lewis v. High A Studs. So Lewis v. Schierholtz: The case for Lewis is that, of all the possibilities, Fred Lewis will work the count. He's still getting on base. Well, a .341 OBP isn't spectacular, but he's basically third on the team, behind Sandoval and Rowand, both of whom have drawn fewer walks than Fred, in way more PA. (I'm not counting Torres, with his 56 PA.) In a lineup with Molina and Sandoval, do we really want another free swinger like Schierholtz? Short term, while Lewis puts in his work in the batting cage, sure--giving Lewis a few days off made sense. But Schierholtz is the definition of a fourth outfielder/PH. A guy with a sweet line drive stroke, who comes off the bench swinging the bat, but with maybe some other deficiencies-like plate discipline--that prevent him playing everyday. He's just a little young to be starting in that role already. (Torres is the definition of the fifth outfielder--really fast, brilliant defensively, and, as a hitter, not an automatic out if you use him on a double-switch.) That leaves Lewis v. Bowker. And of course we don't know that Bowker, if given the LF job, would play significantly better than he did last year. But he's been SO brilliant in AAA, and most of it seems to come down to improved plate discipline. A .300/.400./.540 line, more or less what BP predicts, doesn't seem out of line. And he's three years younger than Lewis. And considerably worse defensively. So your point is well-taken Chris. Lewis has probably been somewhat unlucky this season, and we should expect a stronger second half from him. At the same time, it's fair to suggest that LF is still a problem spot for the Giants. And before trying to solve it via trade, we might--emphasis on might--have a solution in AAA. And guys like Thomas Neal and Roger Kieschnick seem promising in high A, and could play themselves into the long-term picture. I like BP projections for Neal--an EQA of .270, for a 21 year old. That should rise.

Chris
Chris

Something I wanted to work into the main article, but I didn't was that in 2008, Fred Lewis hit an insane: .323/.320/.781 on flyballs. That's good for a sOPS+ of 182. Fred hit 82% better than the league average hitter for flyballs. That's just incredible. And not repeatable most likely for Lewis. Flyballs are turned into outs more than groundballs, but they do more damage when they fall for hits. Lewis was batting over .300 on flyballs in 2008. Even Albert Pujols "only" hit .234/.223/.766 on flyballs in 2008, or an sOPS+ of 135. This year Fred is hitting .135/.135/.514 on flyballs. That's an sOPS+ of 49. He's under the league average for flyballs by 51%. That's a huge hit for any batter to take. Combine that with his drop in BABIP and you've got a struggling hitter. Since most of his underlying numbers are the same, I would think that if his average on flyballs moves back towards league average or at least something respectable and than the current sOPS+ 49 that he's dealing with, Lewis should see a bump in his offensive production. Any thoughts?