Article written by

2 comments
Chris
Chris

I'd probably take Perdomo over Medders -- that's because Medders isn't good -- but Rule 5 picks usually don't stay with the team that drafts them. The Giants can attempt to work out a trade with St. Louis if they wish. It's possible that they might be able to reach some agreement. If not, Perdomo goes back. I was going to analyze his melt down appearance with the A's, but I haven't gotten around to it yet. Perdomo throws hard but he's never had superb control. I wouldn't consider it a big deal if we lose him but I'd rather use Justin Miller over Brandon Medders. The Giants seem to be weighing Perdomo's last appearance against the A's pretty heavily.

delorean
delorean

So... what's the deal with Perdomo? Is this another Sabean screw-up on par with T-Denk, or is he really not worth a roster spot?